John are unwilling to obfuscate the challenge even that much from inside the Sherlock’s presence. John lets Sherlock faith they are upright, but he never shuts you to definitely home completely: strange decisions getting an effective heterosexual guy, but surely reasonable to possess good bisexual son that is looking for a relationship which have Sherlock and you may hopes Sherlock you’ll transform his notice. Even though John will never consciously state “I’m not homosexual” within this earshot from Sherlock, Sherlock really does overhear John claim that to Irene into the A great Scandal in Belgravia – then John tries to has actually a conversation about this with Sherlock, that will be closed.

Think about, John is willing to eliminate individuals to stand near Sherlock, so however however end up being ready to cover-up his sex too

Really, to begin with, Sherlock seemed to really dislike the very thought of John being lured so you’re able to him. It seems sensible John create just date women to save Sherlock of getting the impact. Also, if John tried to day men they might guess he was interested in Sherlock, yet not unfairly. It generates one particular sense for John at this point ladies, and he doesn’t appear to have a problem with it. (Even if, as fair, having John you might not be yes.) It is quite simple to own bisexual individuals real time heterosexual existence: many people are heterosexual and you will assume everyone else is too, very heterosexual matchmaking options appear without needing to feel sought for out.

However, as to why was not John already unlock about it, and just why really does the guy obfuscate the challenge so you can his sister and you may Bill Murray? Really, discover ideas to a whole lot more factors during these early site entries. John try also known as a lady boy prior to getting sent away to Afghanistan, along with The unmistakeable sign of Three our company is demonstrated the smoothness off Big Sholto, a man who John considerably admires and has now a number of the exact same unsociable properties Sherlock enjoys; most likely the caretaker in John are keen on those who have a look mentally wounded and skittish.

And also in wide terms, it might be not surprising if John’s homosexual front side concerned brand new fore as he was in the fresh new armed forces and you may primarily surrounded by men – and even, throughout the Sign of Around three we shall be given big gay connections towards armed forces, and you can Biggest Sholto specifically. Along with, the latest reveal usually reinforce over and over again that sex are crucial that you John. In the event the John has one interest at all to men, it’s not unreasonable to trust he’d work with it inside the an enthusiastic ecosystem in which there were few offered lady.

More telling material, not, would be the fact John’s audience for these “I am not gay” moments is never Sherlock, even even though Sherlock imagine John was hitting on him in the 1st occurrence and other people continuously imagine they have been one or two

Just what occurred within the Afghanistan? We don’t see, however it is not at all difficult to speculate. Perhaps John don’t reach operate inside it, and then he cannot can select. Perhaps it was unrequited, and then he feels unfortunate otherwise bad thinking about unsociable men. Possibly it was requited and concluded poorly. Possibly he performed work on it but there’s tension to help you ensure that it it is miracle and you may, having only returned throughout the conflict, he’s not really sure ideas on how to go about becoming discover regarding they provided their early in the day reputation and his dated loved ones are odd regarding it – not a rare procedure in the event you come-out later on in existence, and Expenses and you may Harry seem to select the tip comedy. And work out a tale regarding the proven fact that John was homosexual wasn’t the quintessential delicate environment they might enjoys developed if John wanted to come out. Or at least John advised himself it had been only because females just weren’t available, but he could be starting to discover maybe it actually was over you to. Possibly the guy will favor people, and you can guys need certainly most popular hookup apps ios to really be a gift. Possibly the guy desires youngsters; John looks happier sufficient when he finds out from Mary’s pregnancy into the The unmistakeable sign of About three. It’s not after all uncommon getting bisexual boys to possess intercourse which have guys however, only go after dating that have females because of this.